How to Safely Ship Trading Cards in 2026 (Pokemon, Baseball, TCG)
Written by Valentin Scemama, Shipping Insurance & Watch Expert at Secursus.
⚡ Quick Answer: The Best Way to Ship Pokemon Cards
To ship a trading card safely, always use the "Penny Sleeve + Top Loader + Team Bag" combo. Sandwich the card between two pieces of cardboard, wrap it in bubble wrap, and place it inside a sturdy shipping box (never a plain envelope). For high-value cards (>$500), use the Double-Boxing method to prevent crushing and theft.
Need to know how to ship a valuable trading card without risking damage? Whether you are sending a Charizard to a buyer or submitting sports cards to PSA, the stakes are high. In 2026, relying on standard carrier packing is a mistake. This guide details the exact trading card shipping supplies and protocols you need to protect your investment.
Shipping Matrix: How to pack?
| Card Value / Type | Packing Method | Insurance |
|---|---|---|
| Raw Card (< $50) | Sleeve + Top Loader + Bubble Mailer | Recommended |
| Graded Slab (PSA/BGS) | Bubble Wrap + Small Box | Essential |
| High Value (> $500) | Double Boxing + Signature | Mandatory |
| Sealed Box / Bulk | Sturdy Box + Void Fill | Essential |
How to Ship Valuable Pokemon, Baseball & Sports Cards
By applying our updated step-by-step guide, you ensure your valuable trading or sports cards arrive safely and remain eligible for full insurance coverage in the event of theft, loss, or damage.
🃏 Current 2026 Packing Standards
- Double-Sleeving: Always put the card in a soft "penny sleeve" first to prevent scratches, then insert it into a Top Loader (for sales) or a Semi-Rigid holder (for grading).
- Restrict Movement: Find a small cardboard box for your cards. Ensure they are well-maintained and that movement is restricted inside with bubble wrap or packing paper. Do not use plain white envelopes (PWE) for valuable cards.
- Double Boxing (The Golden Rule): For high-value items, place this small cardboard box into a larger shipping box. In 2026, we recommend using heavy-duty reinforced tape to prevent tampering.
- Where to buy boxes? Don't rely on flimsy reused Amazon envelopes. For the inner box, use BCW cardboard storage boxes (standard in the hobby). For the outer shipping box, standard 6x4x4 corrugated boxes found at Office Depot, Uline, or Walmart are ideal for structural integrity.
📦 Special Guide: Sending Cards to PSA, BGS, or CGC for Grading
Shipping cards to grading services like PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator) requires a specific protocol different from selling on eBay.
- No Top Loaders: Grading companies prefer Semi-Rigid Card Savers (like Card Saver I) over rigid Top Loaders. Rigid holders can damage the card when the grader attempts to remove it.
- Pull Tabs: Attach a small sticky tab to the penny sleeve to help the grader pull the card out safely.
- Order: Stack your cards in the exact order of your submission form to speed up the process.
Which carrier to ship your sports cards?
It is important to select the best carriers. While USPS Ground Advantage is acceptable for low-value cards (<$100), we strongly recommend FedEx 2Day or UPS Next Day Air for high-value collections.
Why? The less time your package spends in a truck or sorting facility, the lower the risk of crushing or theft. Always make signature delivery mandatory.
🛑 Can I let The UPS Store or FedEx Office pack my cards?
Expert Warning: Many collectors ask if they can pay a store to pack for them. You can let them handle the outer shipping box, but NEVER let a store employee handle the raw card or the sleeving process. They are not trained for collectibles. Pack the inner safety box yourself, seal it, and hand that to the professional packer.
How to insure your cards against loss, theft and damage?
Secursus offers comprehensive coverage for trading cards, up to $120,000 per package. This includes loss, theft, and damage while in transit. Trusted by the hobby community since 2018, Secursus has insured thousands of collectors and dealers, covering over $100 million in trading cards alone.
To insure your cards, simply sign up on Secursus and fill out the brief insurance form before shipping.
2026 Comparison: Carrier vs. Secursus
| Features | Carrier (FedEx/UPS) | Secursus TCG |
|---|---|---|
| Insurance Rate | 1.00% to 3.00% | 0.6% to 1% |
| Claim Speed | 30 - 90 Days | 3 Days Avg |
| Coverage Type | Limited Liability | Full Market Value |
| Max Coverage | Low Caps | Up to $120,000 |
Should you use the carrier’s insurance in 2026?
Carrier insurance in 2026 still often specifically excludes "second-hand goods" or "collectible items" like sports trading cards. We always recommend double-checking the carrier’s fine print. If you’re sending your card to a grading company or a private buyer, standard carrier coverage may not apply to the full market value of the item.
⚠️ Case Study: The Charizard Incident
A collector named Mark once shipped a 1st edition Charizard to PSA for grading. He found the card in an old folder from when he was 12 years old. To ship the card, he chose FedEx with adult signature required. He packed the card well, but placed it in a package so large it could have fit a bike. He mistakenly thought more padding and a massive box meant more safety.
However, because the box was mostly filled with air and soft padding, it lacked structural integrity. During transit, the package collapsed under the weight of heavier freight on a conveyor belt. The box tore open, and the small card slid out unnoticed onto the facility floor, lost forever among the machinery. Mark did not have third-party insurance, so unfortunately, he lost a card worth thousands of dollars. In 2026, with the speed of modern automated sorting centers, proper packaging (Double Boxing) and a specialized insurance policy are no longer optional—they are a necessity.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What are the best shipping supplies for trading cards?
To ship safely, you need: Penny Sleeves (Ultra Pro or similar), Top Loaders (rigid) or Card Savers (semi-rigid for grading), Painter's tape (to seal the holder), and a sturdy Corrugated Cardboard Box (6x4x4 size is ideal). Avoid plain envelopes for anything valuable.
How do I ship a valuable trading card safely?
The safest method is "Double Boxing". Place the card (sleeved and protected in cardboard) inside a small box. Then, place that small box inside a larger shipping box filled with cushioning material. This makes the package harder to lose and protects against crushing.
Does USPS insurance cover Pokemon cards?
USPS insurance can cover collectibles, but claiming the full market value for a card whose price fluctuates (like a Charizard or rookie sports card) can be extremely difficult without a recent sales receipt. Specialized insurance like Secursus is often recommended for items over $100.
